British caravans
Comments
-
Benimar (spanish company being imported by Marquis) have their door on the uk nearside.....
also, one particular 2017 Chausson model (611 Travel Line) has two cab doors and two habitation doors, one on each side, so take your pick....it even has a rear lounge (just as the brits like 'em) with a drop down bed above to avoid cushion shuffling, and
another up front for good measure above four individual captains chairs for travelling and dining......could you actually see a UK company coming up with a radical design like this, let alone have the balls to actually build it and put it into production...
0 -
I'm a Knaus fan and can vouch for the quality
However I've no clue about their motorhomes as I've never looked at them
MichaelT has one.....
ive seen a few at Southdowns in Portsmouth...very well bolted together and lots of good design ideas....as demonstrated by the caravan discussed earlier.
i shall have a real good look at them at the NEC....for reference
0 -
Do german caravans do model with aldi heating and a bathroom which you dont shower over toilet
In a word yes they do, alright three words
Our Hymer 590GL has Alde heating including underfloor, a fan assisted convector in the door way and a warming draw
It has a rear bathroom with seperate shower.
Two of the specific criticisms I had of the Bailey Vigo, which is basically the same layout, were as follows. Firstly although the shower was nice and big, the 1 piece shower door opened outwards so any water collected on the door is going to run onto the washroom carpet
Secondly. The convector at the head on the bed is mounted across the hatch. There is no form of protection, It is inevitable in my opinion that it will get damaged, the fins on this in the 2015 bailey which otherwise was in cosmetically as new condition were already bent. This fault would stop me from buying this van.
This is a YouTube clip showing the layout and construction of a Hymer although it is not the 590 as claimed the washroom is identical
We had alook at a few Hymers the other day, we found they were well constructed, but the worktop in the kitchen area was a bit on the small side, we did not like the narrow fridge as much as our wider Thetford, but mainly we found the shower far too small for our liking.
Our current van os a 2008 Sterling Searcher.
0 -
Do german caravans do model with aldi heating and a bathroom which you dont shower over toilet
In a word yes they do, alright three words
Our Hymer 590GL has Alde heating including underfloor, a fan assisted convector in the door way and a warming draw
It has a rear bathroom with seperate shower.
Two of the specific criticisms I had of the Bailey Vigo, which is basically the same layout, were as follows. Firstly although the shower was nice and big, the 1 piece shower door opened outwards so any water collected on the door is going to run onto the
washroom carpetSecondly. The convector at the head on the bed is mounted across the hatch. There is no form of protection, It is inevitable in my opinion that it will get damaged, the fins on this in the 2015 bailey which otherwise was in cosmetically as new condition
were already bent. This fault would stop me from buying this van.This is a YouTube clip showing the layout and construction of a
Hymer although it is not the 590 as claimed the washroom is identicalI am afraid the weight of them is simply too high for me and with cars getting lighter they will have to get it down.
0 -
Do german caravans do model with aldi heating and a bathroom which you dont shower over toilet
In a word yes they do, alright three words
Our Hymer 590GL has Alde heating including underfloor, a fan assisted convector in the door way and a warming draw
It has a rear bathroom with seperate shower.
Two of the specific criticisms I had of the Bailey Vigo, which is basically the same layout, were as follows. Firstly although the shower was nice and big, the 1 piece shower door opened outwards so any water collected on the door is going to run onto the
washroom carpetSecondly. The convector at the head on the bed is mounted across the hatch. There is no form of protection, It is inevitable in my opinion that it will get damaged, the fins on this in the 2015 bailey which otherwise was in cosmetically as new condition
were already bent. This fault would stop me from buying this van.This is a YouTube clip showing the layout and construction of a
Hymer although it is not the 590 as claimed the washroom is identicalWe had alook at a few Hymers the other day, we found they were well constructed, but the worktop in the kitchen area was a bit on the small side, we did not like the narrow fridge as much as our wider Thetford, but mainly we found the shower far too small
for our liking.Our current van os a 2008 Sterling Searcher.
Frankly I am surprised that you found any kitchen work surface at all. This was a consideration before we bought it, the lack of work surface is offset by the fact that the table is permanently in position. The fridge tall and slim seems common to lots
of vans these days, the only thing we struggle to fit in it we have found is a 4 pint milk container. The shower we find plenty big enough, mind you these days we go into showers one at a time and not together .
I would check if the shower head is high enough. I am only 5'6" so not an issue but I could imagine a 6 footer finding it low.Wildwood heavy no doubt but it is a realistic mptlm not the fantasy figure on most U.K vans.
Like any buying decision you have to weigh up all the pros and cons and come to a decision that. you think is best for you.
0 -
While we could get 2 in our shower (it is double size), we are getting a bit old for that these days
.The kitchen area was MH-sized........do Germans not cook in their caravans/MHs??
As you say, the tall-ish skinny fridge/freezer is used in many vans/MHs now.......only 142l compared to the 175l one we have in our van.
0 -
Kj, most continentals don't cook in their vans. If its a caravan they cook in the awning or bbq, with m/hs they tend to have a fold out flap from their garage door, we've seen lots like this, they either have a gas ring or electric plate that they russell
up something on, along with a lump of bread and a salad there are a lot of them using multi cookers to nowadays, of course the bbq is still the
king.0 -
That's fine in good weather, but what about when it is wet or/and cold?
We too like to cook outside in good weather, but generally prepare the food inside beside the sink, so a bit of workspace is needed. In the continental MHs there mainly seems to be a total lack of any workspace if you are using the sink and/or hob.
0 -
They tend to prepare things at the fixed table, then pass it outside for cooking, even when its raining they just put the canopy out. If the weather is really bad they either eat out or move I
must admit that we brits think differently about meals, they seem to eat much simpler than us. There main concern when buying a m/h seems to be big garage, fixed beds, the rest they just manage with.0 -
It's a box make something bigger something else has to get smaller.
We don't eat a meat and two veg type meal every day so find the cooking facilities fine but that's just us and I don't think a larger kitchen area would make any difference to that.
As we both work our time away is limited but we managed to squeeze nearly three weeks in Spain and France this summer. I realised towards the end of the holiday I had spent less than 5 minutes sitting on the caravan seating in that time. It is different
over there. We are going away this weekend for 2 nights and will probably spend more non sleeping time in it than we did during the whole holiday.Everyone needs to work out what is important to them rather than just blindly following the herd.
0 -
We use part of our awning as additional kitchen and work top space for vegetable preparation etc.
0 -
A bit of a generalisation here but a lot of people who have dogs put up an awning in the winter, porch or otherwise, even if staying for a couple of days. Even if we stay 5 days in the winter, we rarely put the awning up and tend to use the van just like
the house so the kitchen is fairly important to us. When a broad we always put the awning up (minus the sides) but still tend to use the van kitchen0 -
We don't bother putting our awning up if it's only a couple of nights. Our awning is so big that it's a massive task putting it up and then taking it down again.
0 -
MH have a huge space disadvantage over caravans in that they have to fit in an engine, dashboard, driving controls etc...
this takes up approximately 1.5m of the van, so a 7m MH can only have the same space as a 5.5m (internal) caravan....
so, a 'large' MH is viewed as the equivalent to a 'small' caravan.
this means there will be limitations, sometimes in the kitchen, sometimes in the washroom, as i said before with Kjell's search for a potential switch to a MH, you cant just hope to replicate a large caravan with MH thats not at least 1.5m longer.
so, in Kjell's case this would mean a MH of around 9m, or so..
switch your view of the market and start looking at 7 ton, 9m, MH and you will find some very spacious vans, with good kitchens, walk in showers, huge bedrooms, massive storage etc, etc,.....BUT it will cost you 5 times what the caravan did.....
we had a Bolero which was very well designed.....good lounge, nice kitchen, big (enough) bed, tall fridge/freezer, big (enough) washroom/shower, all in 7m.....
however, this wouldnt (necesarily) satisfy someone used to a 7m+ caravan where there was a metre or more internal space...it might feel cramped....
because of this, i feel MH design is far more innovative in that there is always the need to squeeze a little more out of the available space, where (in a way) caravan design could be described as a little 'lazy' as there isnt that pressure on space.
however, things are on the change, with the drive to reduce weights and size to cope with younger campers and their different license groupings....
again, MH design has been looking towards this for years and the drive is well underway for smaller lighter vans....
when you look at the Knaus caravan mentioned earlier, you can see how much bolder the Continentals are in their design and innovations...
it was only a year or so ago that we saw the first drop down beds in uk MH, five years or so after Burstner (then chausson) brought them to mass market, and nearly 30 years after the first german A class vans from Hymer....
so continental vans are generally different, their focus is on different aspects of vanning, sleeping and storage, everything else is done outside.....wheras we seem happy to be sat inside, watching the rain or cooking the roast....
the corresponding lounges and kitchen sizes will reflect this, but, by the same token, so do the large comfortable fixed beds and large garages and lockers of the continental vans.
priorities are different in the two different markets.
0 -
MH have a huge space disadvantage over caravans in that they have to fit in an engine, dashboard, driving controls etc...
this takes up approximately 1.5m of the van, so a 7m MH can only have the same space as a 5.5m (internal) caravan....
so, a 'large' MH is viewed as the equivalent to a 'small' caravan.
this means there will be limitations, sometimes in the kitchen, sometimes in the washroom, as i said before with Kjell's search for a potential switch to a MH, you cant just hope to replicate a large caravan with MH thats not at least 1.5m longer.
so, in Kjell's case this would mean a MH of around 9m, or so..
switch your view of the market and start looking at 7 ton, 9m, MH and you will find some very spacious vans, with good kitchens, walk in showers, huge bedrooms, massive storage etc, etc,.....BUT it will cost you 5 times what the caravan did.....
we had a Bolero which was very well designed.....good lounge, nice kitchen, big (enough) bed, tall fridge/freezer, big (enough) washroom/shower, all in 7m.....
however, this wouldnt (necesarily) satisfy someone used to a 7m+ caravan where there was a metre or more internal space...it might feel cramped....
because of this, i feel MH design is far more innovative in that there is always the need to squeeze a little more out of the available space, where (in a way) caravan design could be described as a little 'lazy' as there isnt that pressure on space.
however, things are on the change, with the drive to reduce weights and size to cope with younger campers and their different license groupings....
again, MH design has been looking towards this for years and the drive is well underway for smaller lighter vans....
when you look at the Knaus caravan mentioned earlier, you can see how much bolder the Continentals are in their design and innovations...
it was only a year or so ago that we saw the first drop down beds in uk MH, five years or so after Burstner (then chausson) brought them to mass market, and nearly 30 years after the first german A class vans from Hymer....
so continental vans are generally different, their focus is on different aspects of vanning, sleeping and storage, everything else is done outside.....wheras we seem happy to be sat inside, watching the rain or cooking the roast....
the corresponding lounges and kitchen sizes will reflect this, but, by the same token, so do the large comfortable fixed beds and large garages and lockers of the continental vans.
priorities are different in the two different markets.
..At last you have cottoned on
0 -
A lot depends on the weather. People sit outside here too when the weather permits. This summer, I spent a lot of time sitting outside. It was simply too hot to stay inside the caravan in contrast to last summer when we had the air-conditioning working! Then when the weather was too hot, we were inside with the windows and doors closed and the aircon on.
0 -
They tend to prepare things at the fixed table, then pass it outside for cooking, even when its raining they just put the canopy out. If the weather is really bad they either eat out or move I must admit that we brits think differently about meals, they seem to eat much simpler than us. There main concern when buying a m/h seems to be big garage, fixed beds, the rest they just manage with.
When we looked at (a lot of!!) MHs just recently, we really liked the lounge area with its swivelling driving seats that are so comfortable. The permanently fitted table was very flexible in that it could be slid and turned in several directions, so having it there all the time would not be a problem for us.
Using it to supplement the kitchen for food prep would be OK, though the height is not ideal for working at.
The MH we really wanted to see was the Hymer Exsis 598, available in both integrated and semi-integrated styles. It proved very difficult to find an example till right at the end of our trip we located one in Darlington.
We had however managed to see a lot of other MHs and had got the feel of the length, and to a certain extent the width of a MH of that size and layout, so only a few details remained to fill in. We also had a lot of info in the Hymer brochure on size of bed, toilet area, shower area and kitchen area.
The problem in the kitchen area is the lack of free workspace, there is plenty if you keep the hob and sink covers in place. The sink was also rather small.
If the appliances were better arranged there would be more usable worktop, Dethleffs have a wider but shallower hob that gives some workspace in front of it.....much more user friendly.
Kitchen storage was very good, but if you want an oven you then lose a bit of that. We reckoned we could do without a gas oven.
The fridge was disappointingly small, a significant drawback.
We had already seen similar "bedrooms", so knew the space would be limited, but the bed size was good.
The low provision of electric sockets was very disappointing. Indeed the basic spec was just that.....very basic.
The deal breaker was the shower area. We had thought it would be big enough as the size was given as 74x74 cm, and similar ones we had tried out felt fine. However, when we did get to try the actual Exsis t-598 in Darlington, we found it felt cramped and the sizes (we took our tapeline) did not match the 74x74 stated. It must depend on where you measure it!
In many caravans and MHs that we looked at recently, both UK and continental, the shower area was very small indeed, and the "wet room" types are very common. Lack of ventilation in many would also be a problem. It seems that many manufacturers are providing a "token" shower room.
The other drawback with the 598 was that in such a narrow van, the pinch point with the toilet opposite the shower was just a bit too narrow for our liking, would be fine in a slightly wider MH.
As we have particular requirements, such as automatic transmission, and ideally wanted a lightweight MH, we reckoned we were looking at having to order a new one to our spec, so we had one dealer price up what we wanted......that was quite a shock! Plus no dealer would entertain moving over our 3 year old air con from our caravan, meaning another 2k+ for new air con.
Even adding only the options which we really wanted (tow bar, autobox and roof mounted air con), or felt were essential, like the more powerful engine, cab air con, spare wheel, some extra sockets etc, for the semi-integrated version we would have been looking at £70k.
Prices are well up for next years models due to the exchange rate.
The idea that certain things, such as kitchen space, in continental caravans and MHs are different to UK built ones, due to a different way of using them does make sense to a certain extent, but the weather, as we know from experience, is not always good, even in France! You cannot always cook outside, and a long trip would become very expensive if you had to keep eating out as cooking meals inside was impractical.
Likewise with dishwashing, and showering, who wants to be trailing to the facilities in the rain?
For a 2-3 week trip, fine, but not for long trips.
0 -
As you are finding out, a m/van is much more of a compromise , when used to the space in equivelant lengths of a c/van ,if you req the same sort of enviroment when touring what ever the weather,
We had numerouse c/vans before we dipped into the "dark side of two m/vans" and found that in the end ,the downsides far outweighed the upside of not towing, we are now positive that it will not be any way back
0 -
Kjell, putting aside JVB's usual 'helpful' post, youve obviously realised that there are 'downsides' to how you currently tour (large caravan, large and expensive towcar) otherwise you wouldnt be foing through the process ypu are at the moment.
so, lets try and be objective.....
firstly, the kitchen....i appereciate that the specific model youve looked at appears to have a small kitchen....its pretty much like the one we have (ours has 6 drawers instead of 4 and may be a tad deeper) but i find this has sufficient space to prep up first, probably with the hob covered, then start to cook with the hob lid up and the sink covered....our oven and fridge/freezer are on the opposite side of the aisle as in the Exsis.
when the meal is finished, the hob is cool, the lid can be closed and dirty crocks sit on the hob lid before washing in the sink and then placed on the drainer (the one i showed you a while back) to drain.
this may be a different process to one you currently use, but we eat in the van around 5 days a week and it seems to present no problem, certainly not one which i would describe as impractical.
the shower thing is also interesting....while many continentals use site services, those that dont, including some pretty hefty German customers, must manage in this shower, its built for the German market, where folk are a little larger than here.
i realise that your personal showering requirements are slightly different to some, but i wouldnt describe a 75cm x 75cm as small or cramped. in the uk we will not trott to the showers, unless its really sunny (short/t-shirt) so we (obviously) use our van shower a lot....
now, i reckon we're within a cm or two of the dimensions above and i reckon we could both get in there should the Rioja take us.....
now, we are both pretty slim, but, seriously there is bags of room to wash more than adequately.
perhaps, a total wildcard to throw into the mix might be the Frankia 640SD......short/light van, very large lounge, good kitchen and across the rear washroom.....all in 6.4m A class....
http://www.motorhomes.co.uk/motorhomes-for-sale/frankia/exclusiv/i640-sd/1749/#prettyPhoto
ok, the downside......for you.....the bed.....its an A class Drop down.....
however, along with Hymer, Frankia have made this into two longitudinal singles (joined at the head end) and comes with a small set of steps (two steps only) to access.....
very large bed, accessible by either occupant without disturbing the other, and a large spacious van when the bed (electric, of course) is swung up out of the way......
good luck, Kjell.....
0 -
Yes, the cooking and washing up goes pretty much the same in our caravan, even though we do have a bit more worktop! OH just thought that in this particular model they had not made the best use of the space, the free space being behind the sink. And the
sink itself is very small. Other vans do have a better kitchen layout within much the same space.We were really surprised by the shower in the 598, we had already stood in a similar one in another MH and thought it plenty big enough. Brochure says 74x74, but at the important "elbow level" it just did not measure up unfortunately.
I think I mentioned earlier that we saw a very good Burstner with a good kitchen and an excellent rear shower room and the longitudinal drop down double bed? 7m long and 2.3m wide.
Access to the bed was OK, 4 belted seats, plus the lounge seating could also make an occasional double by half lowering the drop down bed.
Only drawback was it was a bit too heavy to leave us a decent payload and be within the 3500kg. Hence the decision that I would get my licence back if we decide we want to pursue the MH idea. Choice will be far wider then.
Did not see any Frankias on our travels, but OH has looked at some on line.
We had planned to go to the NEC next week,in caravan. but have had to cancel due to a recently discovered caravan problem. Will maybe go to the Scottish show in February, plus next weekend we hope to view some Dethleffs vans that look good on paper.
0 -
I think there's always a compromise to be made somewhere when moving from an ideal cvan to a MH of modest size.
Our kitchen area in the MH is smaller than in the cvan but we manage very well in much the way BB described. A lift up flap helps as a temporary extension to the work top. It's a matter of getting used to doing things in a different way and is not a problem
at all. Our first (spit) MH had very limited worktop space and we placed a large tray on a seat to use for resting things on. You become innovative.Our big compromise in this MH is the small washroom which is very different from the huge end washroom in the cvan. It's cramped, there's no other way to describe it, but we cope and the rest of the MH suits us fine. After all, how long each day do you spend
in the washroom? To us it is an acceptable compromise.0 -
I'm a Knaus fan and can vouch for the quality
However I've no clue about their motorhomes as I've never looked at them
MichaelT has one.....
ive seen a few at Southdowns in Portsmouth...very well bolted together and lots of good design ideas....as demonstrated by the caravan discussed earlier.
i shall have a real good look at them at the NEC....for reference
Write your comments here...our habitation door is on the UK off side but nit an issue for us. They must do doors on the UK nearside as there is a member if the knaus owners club in Australia that has knew so maybe worth asking if you are serious.
Can vouch for the quality and design especially the kitchen on ours, hob set back so some work space at the front, soft close drawers, tec tower oven etc.
0 -
We do like BB when cooking though I think we do have more space, we also have the ledge/shelf above the front facing passenger seats we use to stand stuff on. We eat and shower in the van most times we are out in it and manage well, the door between lounge
and bedroom is a Jack and Jill type so when using the facilities it's like an en-suite. Also the kitchen is split with huge fridge freezer and oven one side and sink hob etc the other.It is a compromise in a MH but if you have swivel front seats some of the engine space is usable and with those dastardly foreign design touches you can achieve much more in a MH with less space over a British one which in many cases (Bailey) are just a
caravan stuck on the back of a van chassis, even saw one at haycraft this week with a aquaroll and waste master attached!0 -
Kjell, SMC of Newark are the sole distributors for Frankia AFAIK, the link i sent was a ised van from Travelworld, tarded in for a Hymer or N+B i imagine.....wish id seen it earlier, OH would have loved it....
we saw this actual model at the NEC two years ago and thought it great then, however new Frankia are very expensive...hence the desire for a barely used one as above...especially at only 6.4m....
0 -
Just took a look on line at the winibago mini caravan it looks gorgeous and at only 26000 its a steal comes with air conditioning electric awning slide out sides was wondering if they will be at the show
0 -
Kjell, SMC of Newark are the sole distributors for Frankia AFAIK, the link i sent was a ised van from Travelworld, tarded in for a Hymer or N+B i imagine.....wish id seen it earlier, OH would have loved it....
we saw this actual model at the NEC two years ago and thought it great then, however new Frankia are very expensive...hence the desire for a barely used one as above...especially at only 6.4m....
We spent several hours at Travelworld looking at new vans and getting them to price up the Hymer, but their stock at that time was pretty limited. 2016 models sold out and the 2017s not yet arrived, 2nd hand stock was also low and selling fast.
I must say that they were very helpful and pleasant, gave us a lot of their time, but there did not seem to be much of a deal to be done.
We have visited 7 dealers in total so far, none of them were willing to swap over our air con, Gaslow was OK, but we got the impression that that would not be free. We did try some negotiating at Travelworld, but it seems they have no problem shifting all their stock so there was not much movement on price.
Looking at your link, the Frankia is very similar in layout to the Burstner I mentioned above, but with a bigger lounge. And the bed in the Burstner comes even lower, to just above the seat level.
0 -
the Hymer B544 is another in the same vein....like hen's teeth for a recent 2nd hand one.
IMHO, that 2014 Frankia would be far better built than the Burstner (IT 680 G?) but it is shorter and the Burstner has a garage in its extra length.
if thinking about the 680, have a very close look at the (nicer, IMHO) Dethleff 4-travel....same van, but a tad more upmarket.
also, the new Dethleffs Globebus look interesting....slim, light A class..
0