Red Pennant and Sanef autoroute in France

Surfer
Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
500 Comments 100 Likes

It is my understanding from various other posts that only Sanef breakdown vehicles can recover you if you break down on an autoroute in France.

If you have Red Pennant does the same apply?  Do you phone Red Pennant for recovery or use the Sanef phone on the French autoroute and who pays if the driver asks for payment?  Thanks. 

 

«1

Comments

  • TheShipmans
    TheShipmans Club Member Posts: 47 ✭✭
    edited May 2016 #2

    Only time I needed assistance, phoned Red Pennant & was told to use Autoroute phone. Had to pay driver cash. Cleared us out of cash to the extent that we couldn't buy a baguette on campsite next morning

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #3

    Only time I needed assistance, phoned Red Pennant & was told to use Autoroute phone. Had to pay driver cash. Cleared us out of cash to the extent that we couldn't buy a baguette on campsite next morning

    That is very worrying as we carry very little cash with us and we have paid for breakdown cover with RP.

  • ValDa
    ValDa Forum Participant Posts: 3,004 ✭✭
    500 Likes 1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #4

    Our experience was a bit different.

    On an autoroute you have to use the roadside phone - and you are generally asked if you have breakdown insurance and if so, who with.  In the one instance we broke down years ago we used the roadside phone, and were told a truck would be on the way, but they also then transferred us to the AA Call Centre in Lyon (we had AA cover) and the arrangement to pay the driver was made by the AA so we had no cash to find. 

    On another forum there is a long thread about ADAC and paying for recovery from the autoroute, but on that occasion the fee (paid in cash) was refunded by ADAC after the event.

    Perhaps one of the Caravan Club staff can comment as to how payment/refund of payment is handled by Red Pennant.

     

  • eurortraveller
    eurortraveller Club Member Posts: 6,830 ✭✭✭
    2,500 Likes 1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #5

    The autoroute breakdown service will tow you off the motorway. Then in a safe place they will take your Red Pennant details and bill the charges to them. Been there, done it! 

  • TheShipmans
    TheShipmans Club Member Posts: 47 ✭✭
    edited May 2016 #6

    I would add that having paid driver (it was to change caravan wheel after a blowout) I was refunded in full on return to UK

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #7

    I would add that having paid driver (it was to change caravan wheel after a blowout) I was refunded in full on return to UK

    If you have breakdown insurance you should nto have to pay any one at any time even if you are refunded on your return otherwise what is the point of insurance.  If you have personal cover and suffer an issue, does that mean you have to pay and then reclaim
    on your return to the UK.

    Either way you lose financially on your holiday!  BTW nothing in the RP brochure regarding this issue.

  • eurortraveller
    eurortraveller Club Member Posts: 6,830 ✭✭✭
    2,500 Likes 1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #8

    Yes,  I can think of all sorts of emergency situations where you may well have to pay up front and reclaim later - so take good credit cards with enough headroom to cover those events which may arise. 

     

  • ValDa
    ValDa Forum Participant Posts: 3,004 ✭✭
    500 Likes 1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #9

    Even if you have health insurance, and you have occasion to visit a French doctor, you have to pay up front and then reclaim the money from your insurers after the event.

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #10

    Morning everyone

    On page 10 of the Red Pennant Assistance booklet, there is information on what you need to do if you break-down on the Autoroutes in France.

    Once you have called the police to arrange recovery, you need to call Red Pennant and they will contact the company that is recovering you to ask them if they will accept payment from Red Pennant. In 85% of cases the break-down company will accept payment from Red Pennant. If the break-down company refuses to accept the payment from Red Pennant, then you will need to pay, and claim the cost back.

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #11

    Morning everyone

    On page 10 of the Red Pennant Assistance booklet, there is information on what you need to do if you break-down on the Autoroutes in France.

    Once you have called the police to arrange recovery, you need to call Red Pennant and they will contact the company that is recovering you to ask them if they will accept payment from Red Pennant. In 85% of cases the break-down company will accept payment
    from Red Pennant. If the break-down company refuses to accept the payment from Red Pennant, then you will need to pay, and claim the cost back.

    Thanks Hazel.  Any idea of approximately how long it takes to get the refund?

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #12

    Hi Surfer

    The time it takes to be paid for a claim depends on how busy the claims department is. At the moment (low season) it takes approximately 5-10 working days to pay the claim once the claim form has been received.

    In high season, it can take 5-15 working days.

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #13

    Trying to access the info I get the following message;

    Page not found

    No umbraco document matches the url 'http://www.caravanclub.co.uk/insurance/overseas-holiday-insurance'

    umbraco tried this to match it using this xpath query'/root/*/* [@urlName = "insurance"]/* [@urlName = "overseas-holiday-insurance"] | /root/* [@urlName = "overseas-holiday-insurance"]')

    This page can be replaced with a custom 404 page by adding the id of the umbraco document to show as 404 page in the /config/umbracoSettings.config file. Just add the id to the '/settings/content/errors/error404' element.

    For more information, visit information about custom 404 on the umbraco website.

    This page is intentionally left ugly ;-)

     

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #14

    Morning everyone

    On page 10 of the Red Pennant Assistance booklet, there is information on what you need to do if you break-down on the Autoroutes in France.

    Once you have called the police to arrange recovery, you need to call Red Pennant and they will contact the company that is recovering you to ask them if they will accept payment from Red Pennant. In 85% of cases the break-down company will accept payment from Red Pennant. If the break-down company refuses to accept the payment from Red Pennant, then you will need to pay, and claim the cost back.

    Hazel I am looking at page 10 of the Red Pennant Motoring Only cover booklet right now, and there is no mention about a breakdown company and Sanef toll roads.

    I can find no mention of it in the booklet anywhere?

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #15

    Hi Surfer

    It is in the assistance booklet (issue 15) which is sent out to you when you have taken out a policy.

    Best regards

    Hazel

     

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #16

    Hi Surfer

    It is in the assistance booklet (issue 15) which is sent out to you when you have taken out a policy.

    Best regards

    Hazel

     

    The booklet sent to us is Issue 16M?

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #17

    Hi Surfer

    16m is the policy booklet, which gives details about the cover that you have.

    Issue 15 is the assistance booklet which gives details of what you need to do and who you need to call if you need assistance.

    When you take out a policy, you should get both booklets.

    One policy booklet (16M) , and one assistance booklet (issue 15).

    Best regards

    hazel

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #18

    Hi Surfer

    16m is the policy booklet, which gives details about the cover that you have.

    Issue 15 is the assistance booklet which gives details of what you need to do and who you need to call if you need assistance.

    When you take out a policy, you should get both booklets.

    One policy booklet (16M) , and one assistance booklet (issue 15).

    Best regards

    hazel

    Hi Hazel, I have been through all my files and drawers and cannot find the assistance booklet you mention.  I cannot even find a copy of it on the CC website.  I have also check all my emails regarding my cover and no Assistance booklet attached.  Can you
    please provide a link to this booklet or email me a copy?  Thanks.

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #19

    Morning Surfer

    Can you e-mail me: hazel.havell@caravanclub.co.,uk I can e-mail you back a PDF of the assistance booklet, or send you a copy in the post.

    Please let me know in your e-mail which option you would prefer.

    Many thanks

    Hazel

     

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #20

    When you do the quote Online, the only thing you see before paying is the Policy Summary and the Policy Booklet.  Neither of which mention the autoroute restrictions.  No Assistant booklet is available to view. 

    As we are travelling on a budget this could have a serious knock on effect on our holiday should be unfortunate enough to suffer a breakdown like a puncture on an autoroute.  Other have advised that we should take out a credit card just in case, but as we
    leave for France on Thursday, it will not arrive in time.

    Surely something like this should be made very obvious prior to purchasing the Red Pennant cover?  At least you then know to make sure that you have sufficient funds to cover such an emergency. 

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #21

    Hi Surfer

    I will pass your comments to the Red Pennant team.

    Below is confirmation from one of the Duty officers regarding the law in France:

    It is the law in France that only recovery vehicles sent by the police can enter motorways in France and unfortunately there is nothing Red Pennant can do to change this. If we tried to send someone, they would refuse as they could very likely lose their
    licence.  Requesting assistance is done by picking up the orange phone and the police will immediately know your location.  We advise members to call us once the assistance arrives.  We then speak to the recovery person and ask if he will accept our guarantee
    for payment.  It is up to the garage whether they will or not, but from experience, most have heard of the Caravan Club and will accept this.  If the garage will not accept our payment, then members will need to pay  and Red Pennant will reimburse you for
    the recovery once you have submitted your claim. The vehicle/outfit is then usually towed back to the garage and we ask members to contact us once they are there, so we can then fully take over and assist in the normal way.

    The same rules apply to all break-down policies in France. The AA, RAC, ADAC are in exactly the same position. In 85-90 % of cases the recovery company will accept the Caravan Club guarentee.

     

     

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #22

    Hi Surfer

    I will pass your comments to the Red Pennant team.

    Below is confirmation from one of the Duty officers regarding the law in France:

    It is the law in France that only recovery vehicles sent by the police can enter motorways in France and unfortunately there is nothing Red Pennant can do to change this. If we tried to send someone, they would refuse as they could very likely lose their
    licence.  Requesting assistance is done by picking up the orange phone and the police will immediately know your location.  We advise members to call us once the assistance arrives.  We then speak to the recovery person and ask if he will accept our guarantee
    for payment.  It is up to the garage whether they will or not, but from experience, most have heard of the Caravan Club and will accept this.  If the garage will not accept our payment, then members will need to pay  and Red Pennant will reimburse you for
    the recovery once you have submitted your claim. The vehicle/outfit is then usually towed back to the garage and we ask members to contact us once they are there, so we can then fully take over and assist in the normal way.

    The same rules apply to all break-down policies in France. The AA, RAC, ADAC are in exactly the same position. In 85-90 % of cases the recovery company will accept the Caravan Club guarentee.

     

     

    This is our first time to France so we were not aware of the above rulling and assume that when we took out the Red Pennant we woudl be covered for all eventualities regarding breakdown.  At no time were we informed of the above. 

    We are not disputing it, but feel that we should have been made aware of this restriction when taking out the policy.  I am wondering how many other people have bene caught out with this?

    We are now looking at alternative insurance who offer the same cover as part of our current account as we now feel that we were misled by Red Pennant.  We appreciate that there will be the same restrictions mentioned above, but at at least we would not be
    paying £209 upfront. 

  • EmilysDad
    EmilysDad Forum Participant Posts: 8,973
    1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #23

     .....  Other have advised that we should take out a credit card just in case,  ...

    You don't already have one? Surprised

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #24

    Hi Surfer

    I am very sorry that you feel misled by the Club, I will make sure that a copy of your comments are sent to the Red Pennant team. I will reply to your e-mail and send you the PDF shortly.

    Best regards

    Hazel

     

  • EmilysDad
    EmilysDad Forum Participant Posts: 8,973
    1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #25

     .....

    This is our first time to France so we were not aware of the above rulling and assume that when we took out the Red Pennant we woudl be covered for all eventualities regarding breakdown.  At no time were we informed of the above. 

    We are not disputing it, but feel that we should have been made aware of this restriction when taking out the policy.  I am wondering how many other people have bene caught out with this?

    We are now looking at alternative insurance who offer the same cover as part of our current account as we now feel that we were misled by Red Pennant.  We appreciate that there will be the same restrictions mentioned above, but at at least we would not be
    paying £209 upfront. 

    I'm not really sure what you have a problem with. Plenty of insurances will expect you to pay for the goods/services & then be reimbursed later .... I' think in some cases I'd prefer that eg if you were replacing a hosehold item would you expect your insurance
    to pay the supplier direct?

    And surely all insurance is paid for up front

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #26

     .....  Other have advised that we should take out a credit card just in case,  ...

    You don't already have one? Surprised

    We are retired and use a debit card so no debt to pay every month why would we need a credit card?

  • eurortraveller
    eurortraveller Club Member Posts: 6,830 ✭✭✭
    2,500 Likes 1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #27

    Surfer, do please take sufficient funds and cards to cope with emergencies. Doctors, vets, replacement tyres, batteries, silencers, broken windscreens, replacement of stolen property,  will all have to be paid for up front then reclaimed.

    Change your insurance company if you wish, but none of them will send a man with a money bag to follow you around France paying bills for you. But I hope your first tour of France goes well and that no problems arise. Do please let us know about it when you are back. Good luck. 

     

  • cyberyacht
    cyberyacht Forum Participant Posts: 10,218
    1000 Comments
    edited May 2016 #28

    What gets me with all these insurances, not just RP, is the plethora of T&C, Key Features, Policy Document, Supplementary Conditions, Guides and leaflets. It would take you a major part of a two week holiday to check through to see if the incident was covered
    anyway. The KISS principle seems to have escaped them completely.

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #29

    I'm not really sure what you have a problem with. Plenty of insurances will expect you to pay for the goods/services & then be reimbursed later .... I' think in some cases I'd prefer that eg if you were replacing a hosehold item would you expect your insurance
    to pay the supplier direct?

    And surely all insurance is paid for up front

    Please read my email properly before commenting.  The issue is not the payment, but the fact that we were never informed upfront about this abnormality with Sanef autoroute.  Hazel is doing her best to resolve the issue, but I feel that members should be
    made aware of this issue.

  • Surfer
    Surfer Club Member Posts: 1,303
    500 Comments 100 Likes
    edited May 2016 #30

    Surfer, do please take sufficient funds and cards to cope with emergencies. Doctors, vets, replacement tyres, batteries, silencers, broken windscreens, replacement of stolen property,  will all have to be paid for up front then reclaimed.

    Change your insurance company if you wish, but none of them will send a man with a money bag to follow you around France paying bills for you. But I hope your first tour of France goes well and that no problems arise. Do please let us know about it when you are back. Good luck. 

     

    Thanks. Hopefuly we have sufficient savings to cover most eventualities without resorting to a credit card, but it means transferring the money into a current account for "just in case".  The issue is that the CC Red Pennant should be clearer regardaing policies and not omit details and this what Hazel is doing.

  • Hazel
    Hazel Forum Participant Posts: 185
    edited May 2016 #31

    Hi Surfer

    I have just e-mailed you a PDF of the Assistance booklet. As the e-mail has an attachment it might go directly to your Spam or Junk box. Can you let me know if you have received it OK?

    I hope you have a trouble free holiday, and you have a great time

    Thanks

    Hazel