Van nearly overweight
I have just had my van serviced and one of my requests was to have the van weighed.This was completed by the dealer but to my dismay I only have 4kg left.
Payload is 155kg
The van has a motor mover fitted,and battery was in position,it is a 4 berth van.Underneath the fixed bed are two dorema chairs and leg rests,kitchen consists of pans and frying pan with lids and cutlery plates small tea cups.I carry tea bags and coffee in a plastic container.
Under off side locker empty,along with nearside locker. along with all top cupboards.
Washroom,cleaning fluid,polish,spare toilet rolls,toothbrushes,toothpaste ect deodorant sprays.
All of the above essentials that I leave in the van all year around., this leave absolutely nothing now for touring I cannot even load it with clothing or food,drinks,television ect.
How with the exception of having the motor mover removed can this be acceptable.This is primarily a two berth but has the front beds to make it four.
Incidentally, I asked about a plate upgrade,to be informed you can only apply this in the first year,
Anyone have a solution,apart from packing everything in the car when touring.
Comments
-
Incidentally, I asked about a plate upgrade,to be informed you can only apply this in the first year,
What make is it.
User payload is generally arrived at by the formula 10L+10N+50 where L is internal length. N is no of berths and result in Kg.
Even a couple in a 4 berth would struggle. Ours is a three berth and would give 54+30+50= 134lg. Take off mover, battery and spare gas and I reckon we would have 80kg at most. We upgraded giving extra 100kg.
0 -
Incidentally, I asked about a plate upgrade,to be informed you can only apply this in the first year,
I would push them on this. Nothing has happened in the first year to make an upgrade invalid. They are just being awkward for the sake of it. I upgraded my Bailey when I got it at five years old.
0 -
You could have a heavier duty axle fitted to the caravan. Such a modification would theoretically require an IVA if the manufacturer, in this case Coachman, won’t support it, but that sort of thing is not cheap and therefore only worth doing if you intend to keep the caravan for a long time.
0 -
Before I gave up on an upgrade I would contact Coacman direct if you have not already done so.
The angle I was coming from was no wonder so many axles have issues with such tight loading margins.
Not really. Without having the upgrade the plated MPTLM on the side of van could be well below axle limit. You might find that your axle limit is 1,800 kg
0 -
It's worth checking the spec of your axle, many at or within 50kg of the MTPLM. Generally these are the ones with suspension problem. It's on a sticker in the middle of the axle. Yo should be limited you have a 100kg plus headroom.
As you have found 150kg is an inadequate load margin, my van from 10 years ago had 220kg and 20 years ago 300kg. The formula adopted by the industry only makes any sense if there is a reasonable MRO allowance which in general there isn't. The formula should have been regarded as a minimum allowance not the maximum. Such is progress
0 -
Poor payloads on new vans is one of the main reasons we are hanging on to our 2008 model for as long as possible!
Our original payload was 283kg, but that has to include everything as in those days there were no allowances in the MIRO for gas or anything.
We upgraded to 1900kg, so now have 368kg allowance, and use pretty much all of it as we have fitted mover, air con and various other extras over the years.
0 -
I have the 2016 version of your caravan.
I removed the spare wheel and carrier, the wheel lives in the car spare wheel well. Manufacturer no longer supplies a spare for the car but does the space. Carpets are in the attic.
I have the weight plate upgrade, not sure about the in a year thing as you said, all I needed was the registration card.
Only the two of us, no awning or pegs in the caravan, but if you add the axle load and hitch load I'm over weight.
I weighed it recently axle was 1510kg, which is 40kg under the axle load.
If I had to shed weight I wouldnt know what to loose, theirs not that much personal stuff in here.
I would phone Coachman about up-plating.
0 -
To All
Thanks for all the replies.Yes I am planning to write to Coachman for a plate upgrade.
I have found the rating plate on the axle and it is only rated to 1550kg just 40kg more.
Along with removing stuff like carpets,cutting the handles down on my toothbrushes I am just not sure where any savings can be made.
0 -
Our previous version of the Clubman ES only gained 45kg.
Maybe save a bit on gas bottles. I am always on EHU so use 3.9kg size. Maybe block off half of OH's wardrobe. Some take off Alko wheel carrier and stow wheel under the bed. We carry our chairs and tables in the boot of car.
I know that we carry more than the absolute minimum but payloads are daft. Looking at the formula 10L+10N+50: The 50 is OK it is the 10kg per person that is daft. Hell on an air flight you get a 23kg two bag allowance per person. The majority of caravanners have a motor mover. In fact they are included in first purchase with some caravans but not in MIRO.
0 -
Its tight.
I weighed every item into the van when new.
I was 15kg ish over.
I no longer carry the awning in the van.
I also gained by removing stuff we don't use:
Table 5.3kg
Spare wheel carrier 6.4Kg
Sink drainer 0.3kg
Steady wrench 0.9kg
I also use a Safefill that saves a lot on bottle weight.
As a point of order, I really do try to stay legal but assuming I was stopped by the law, would the axle weight prevail or the MTPLM?
0 -
In our previous van, we removed the lift up bunk, which was quite heavy, as there were only 3 of us to cater for, in our present van we rarely carry the big table, that saves several kg.
We used to have a Fiamma canopy on the van, and the zip on sides in the car, but after it fell apart 2 years back we decided not to replace it, and now use a lightweight canopy which takes up much less space in the car too.
We do not carry any outside tables or chairs in the van, only items that are for use in the van, Aquaroll travels in the car, but Wastemaster is in the front locker.
I used to keep a toolbox in the van, that has now been moved to the car as we have more space in it now.
We also went through the kitchen equipment fairly ruthlessly and weeded out the extra plates, little used utensils etc, and stopped taking books to read with us.
Like most vans, even with our decent payload, we have far more space in which we could carry things than we have the weight allowance to do so.
0 -
I had a similar experience as the OP when I took our 2015 Barcelona to the weigh bridge, last year. With even less equipment in it than the OP reports, it was still 20kg over - albeit with an AWD motor mover fitted. Absolutely ridiculous.
It was one of the reasons why, when we changed our van that I went for a German manufactured one which has a sensible payload of 360kg but I still carry all the heavy stuff in the car. What I don’t understand is since most vans use an Alko chassis - why is there so much difference?
0 -
The UK makers payload limits are all but criminal IMO as typically used many vans will be overloaded. The makers and dealers must know a battery is a norm as is for most users a mover, but there is no provision in their trade associations NCC's formula for that 60 -75 kgs.
It was a factor why we when German where the option was to have far greater payloads, our first was 330 kgs. The current was contracted at 300 though turned out overweight and we settled for a slight loss. Weight ratings were on the options list.
If we left the dealers holding unsold stock with these pathetic payload vans, I am sure the industry would change; it needs buyers looking at this seriously before buying and before being seduced by the more visual features.
In reality the axle load whilst towing will be the noseweight less than the van's actual weight. This raises the question what do the authorities weigh and compare with the VIN plate, the axle weight or the van's stand alone weight?
0 -
We keep our van in storage so not so easy to move things in and out but since we started to caravan we have always put all heavy items, awning etc in the car.
Things like table and chairs live in the van as that is where they are used and I would not be confident that we are not overweight so have decided, prompted by this thread, that its time to get the van, in as used loading, weighed.
Using the formula that Easy quoted, which I have never heard of so thanks for that, I would be 57.69+40+50= not a lot.
0 -
Using the formula that Easy quoted, which I have never heard of so thanks for that, I would be 57.69+40+50= not a lot.
I have seen the formula on a number of makers websites and it appears in my Caravan Handbook. It is daft. My present Clubman ES is the same model as my previous one. The only difference is that the bunk which would be used over the spare bed is optional whereas previously it was included. The previous van had a MPTLM of 1,435 Kg. I removed the main table and mattresses, bunk sides etc and replated to 1,495kg I think. So on paper a 60kg upgrade plus the gain on items removed. Also 12kg allowance for water and so flush empty and hot tank drained gave another 12Kg
Without the bunk the present one would have had a 1,400 kg MPTLM but upgraded to 1500Kg. I am positive that the majority of caravanners have never weighed their caravan.
In 2012 the MIRO included an allowance of 15Kg for two 5kg BP gas lite bottles, 10kg in water heater and 2 kg in the toilet flush. (I wonder how we are supposed to carry this 5kg of gas? Presumably in a plastic bag!)
Fast forwards to 2018 (change was earlier) and allowance for gas bottles only 8 Kg and no allowance for 12kg of water and so caravan becomes 19kg lighter straight away. For many that reduces available payload by 19 kg
I am certain that the majority of caravanners, like myself, have never been near a weighbridge. But the sadder thing is that, in my experience, dealers never offer the weight upgrade option to the unwary. Why would anybody with a full licence to tow not wish an upgrade.
0 -
Why would anybody with a full licence to tow not wish an upgrade.
Requested when ordering and gives me an extra 50kg on top of the 155kg standard.
0 -
Fozzie, it might be worth getting your caravan reweighed on a public weighbridge and see if the weights come out similar.
Our caravan's plated MRO is 1156kg but the weighbridge gave me a figure of 1109kg. The question is, of course, which one is correct? I go for the figure from the public, council run, weighbridge on the basis that they are weighing vehicles all day long and guess that the system is calibrated regularly.
That said, and erring on the side of caution, I have always used the plated figure and, sad as it may seem, know the weight of just about everything that goes in the 'van. I keep a self totaling excel spreadsheet so that if I add or remove anything I can very quickly know what my total weight is and what spare capacity I have from my 1350kg MTPLM.
Another thing to check is what is actually included in the MRO figure. Bizarrely Lunar include 8kg for gas, 10kg of water in the heater and 5kg for the hook up cable. I never travel with water in the heater and the hook up cable can, if necessary, travel in the car. Why a battery is not included is very strange. Other manufacturers may list different things in their MRO so it's worth checking. There ought to be an agreed standard that nothing 'extra' is included.
0 -
I have recently completed a weight audit for our Lunar Clubman and wrote about it on my website. This may be of some help to others.
I have come to the conclusion that we will have to dispense with the Fiamma roll out awning and return to a traditional porch awning since this can be carried in our car. This change will give us a much needed additional 15Kg which should cover my wife's shoe bag.
0 -
On our previous Lunar we took all the tv brackets and stored them as we don’t bother with TV. Never carry a bbq. No pet stuff to lug around. Took the wheel carrier off the van and carried the spare in the car.
Will get the Coachman weighed in the next couple of weeks so that will be interesting.
1 -
The first thing I did when picking up new TA van in March this years was go straight to the council weigh bridge, motor mover fitted and 110ah battery and whatever was in the van from new. Taken straight to storage site and when home weighed everything that was going back in the new van, even put all cutlery in a carrier bag and weighed that. My updated weight plate went from 1840kg to 2000kg and worked out I have about 100kg left to play with.
0 -
"The first thing I did when picking up new TA van in March this years was go straight to the council weigh bridge"
i had the dealer weigh our MH before I collected it.....the deal was subject to weight limits I had 'self imposed' so as to enable the new van to 'work' at 3500kg knowing the weight of all the 'stuff' that was to be carried on our long trips away.
each van (MH or caravan) can vary +/- 5% from manufacturers figures (and therefore, the plated weight).
5% of a 3500kg MH is 175kg, that's a lot to be out by....but it might still work
5% of a 1500kg caravan is 75kg which is probably a killer...
i know what we weighed prior to sale, in a known state...I knew what I was planning to load....I weighed the van in full touring trim and was only 20kg out....I know exactly what spare capacity I have and what wine weighs
id get any new vehicle (MH or caravan) weighed prior to completing the deal. no ne wants an unusable van with no upgrade path available.
0 -
Having moved back to a caravan last September from a MH it was quite a shock to find how little weight allowance we had compared to all our previous caravans.
How families manage I do not know. We up plated our van on buying but we only got a further 35kg, just enough to cover the mover.
In the past we put just about everything in the van, we used to carry 2 gas bottles, steel not lites. Bedding for 4, cutlery and crockery for 4 and of course clothes for 4.
Now we have 2 each of these things, a few clothes and toiletries. Food spare clothes, tool box, cycle kit, sun canopy, chairs, bbq etc goes in the car. If we were to take children with us they would have to sit on the car roof
Payloads on british vans are a joke, time to go back to a decent axle rather than the lightweight one now fitted to british vans
1 -
We do not have a problem with pay load in our c/van as we do now as we have always done (before weight "worries?")when caravan chassis alone probably weighed nearly as much as some modern complete caravans, but then as now we have a mobile attachable support vehicle that carries and excess we may need on long tours as now and as said in my previos post thing will not change soon,in fact it may get worse in the future,and I can see with the proliferation of motor caravans and most it seems used as just a get to some where and stay as with caravans, site that are not close to any transport/towns getting less use and some even closing
0 -
Before we used to have 2 teens and a dog in the car. Awning in boot with a few other bits (heavy). As stated everything else for the holiday went in the caravan.
We now have a Kuga and even with the rear seats down the car is full of kit, we don't use an awning so that's one thing less, as said where do families put the kids.
0 -
Just the usual stuff, food, bike helmuts and saddle bags, tool box, sun canopy, ground sheet bbq, books/maps, wheel lock, leveller, satellite dish, tripod, spare clothes, bedding and towels. Cool box for bottles of juice etc. Lounge chairs and small table. Everything for a 2 month trip abroad
0