Electric Cars

2»

Comments

  • redface
    redface Forum Participant Posts: 1,701
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #32

    N1805 - don't worry, local power networks will be able to cope with charging, say, 25% cars overnight whilst at home  or at pre-determined charging points throughout the country whilst en route.

    When putting in points the  potential load factors are taken into account including future proofing. Where they might be short, the local cabling network is usually beefed up to cope.

    Tigi - don't panic, go to the nearest Nissan dealer (if you have one of their cars) they will express charge you for free (currently.)

    Me - I am waiting for Tessla to crack the battery problem and sell me a sports car that will do 600 miles per charge. I guess it may be a few years yet!

     

  • twoexplorers
    twoexplorers Forum Participant Posts: 4
    edited February 2017 #33

    I can only afford to run one car, which has two functions, one as tow car and  the other daily use. I am feeling that there is a lot of pressure on diesel car owners to reflect on the damage they are doing because of the pollution. I would consider owning a hybrid electric / petrol  which could tow, especially if the club negotiated some incredible prices for its members. As for electric cars, they  may be good for commuters over shorter distances but they are, as yet, impractical as a main family car with the multiple demands of such transport..

     

  • IanH
    IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
    1000 Comments
    edited February 2017 #34

    Untill battery technology improves to the point that cars can go 300 miles minimum on a full charge and then re-charge within a few minutes, then they will not be viable outside of London and maybe a few other cities.

    Meanwhile, 'normal' petrol and diesel cars are just fine. Where's the problem?

  • Mr H
    Mr H Forum Participant Posts: 356
    100 Comments
    edited February 2017 #35

    We have gone from being encouraged by the Government to use diesel to it being unacceptable. Will electric power suffer a similar fate? All those magnetic fields around will I am sure get a 'body of experts' on the case. And the environmentalists will start working on the effects of disposing of batteries.

  • malc1945
    malc1945 Forum Participant Posts: 74
    edited February 2017 #36

    I wonder what is the life of these batteries are thy likely to expire in say five years or so . And what would be the cost to replace, or are they leased some one told me they were but I have not seen or read any thing on this. our local outlet shopping centre as two or three charging points so as ASDA mind you,  you  would never get onto one of  there, more often than not you will find the parking area for them filled up with other cars. I often comment look there is an electric  Mondeo  astra  and such like, 

  • trevoliver
    trevoliver Forum Participant Posts: 21
    edited February 2017 #37

    We tow with a Mitsubishi Phev tows fine we tow a bailey unicorn Vigo tows a dream great car to drive once you have driven one you wouldn't go back to a noisey Diesel engine if driven locally about 30 miles per day you never go to a garage 

  • redface
    redface Forum Participant Posts: 1,701
    1000 Comments
    edited February 2017 #38

    I would be rather concerned (in London) if everyone bought an electric car, that the cables under the roads would not be able to take the strain of required levels of current.

    That would need one heck of an infrastructure rebuild.

    Hopefully the rate of demand will increase slowly.

  • Takethedogalong
    Takethedogalong Forum Participant Posts: 17,044 ✭✭✭
    10,000 Likes 1000 Comments Name Dropper Photogenic
    edited February 2017 #39

    FCEV cars (hydrogen) will be the ultimate way forward outside of cities. Capable of loads, fast refuel, greater mileage. However, at present the refuelling infrastructure is almost none existent, around a dozen recharge stations. (Recharge is similar to LPG). Oil is still king in this country and until that changes, (the sooner the better, then we can tell the oil producing countries to you know what!) there is not a deal of incentive for anyone outside of cities to change.

    I cannot get my head around electric cars? If the electricity is being produced by anything other than wind, solar or wave ( i.e fossil fuel of one sort or another) then all it is doing is moving the pollution elsewhere? So what is the point? Makes the new owner feel all eco and  green, but not really helping much in the overall scale of things? 

    Long way to go yet. By all means put a large tax on owning a diesel in London, the rich will pay it, those who can't have the largest transport budget to compensate them towards other ways of getting around. Other areas of the country don't have the option.

  • ChemicalJasper
    ChemicalJasper Forum Participant Posts: 437
    edited February 2017 #40

    Hydrogen is typically made from steam reforming of natural gas or by electrolysis (needing electricity to make it), so probably worse than battery technology with regards to environmental credentials!

    Whilst it has the convenience of petrol / diesel in that it takes only minutes to refill, it is far more dangerous!

    Hydrogen has the widest explosive range of any gas and the lowest ignition energy (certainly static from cloths rubbing) and is very searching being such a small molecule. Any leaks would almost always result in an explosive cloud.

    There are also other technical difficulties in the storage and transport of hydrogen.

    Just something to keep in mind!

  • IanH
    IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
    1000 Comments
    edited February 2017 #41

    I understand that most come with a 'payment plan' to cover the eventual cost of replacing the expensive batteries. So not quite as cheap to run as first appears.

    Does anyone know - when people plug into those charging points in car parks etc. do you pay for it? I assume so, but never really looked that closely.

  • Metheven
    Metheven Club Member Posts: 3,987 ✭✭✭
    1,500 Likes 1000 Comments
    edited February 2017 #42

    I don't think electric is practical for everyone and everyday use, already service stations are begining to charge extortionate amounts for the charging of vehicles, when only last year it was free.

    The range is not there for most of us but for some uses it is ideal. To give you an idea of battery longevity my daughter runs the only electric fleet of taxis in Cornwall and is retiring her first one bought in 2013.
    Her Generation 2 Nissan LEAF 'Wizzy' has been rapid charged 3786 times & Level 2 charged 8925 times in three and a half years, and covered 170,000 miles at 2p per mile.
    Granted they have to go some way yet to improve the range but she swears by their reliability and fuel savings compared to the old diesel fleet. Also servicing costs are minimal with no drive train, axles, engine etc.

    They have single phase charging points at their home/premises but also rent a small industrial unit with the availability of 3 phase rapid charging pods, unfortunately not everyone has this option.

  • ABM
    ABM Forum Participant Posts: 14,578
    1000 Comments
    edited February 2017 #43

    From  this  months ( March 2017 )  Vintage  Spirit  Magazine  :--

    The  Magazine  for  Steam  and  Industrial  Heritage  Enthusiasts

    Back  To  The  Future  ==  Hull  Streetlife  Museum   Article  has  a 

    series  of  pictures  and  notes  about  early  1900s  vehicles  of  which 

    one  is  rather  like  a  four  wheeled,  two  seater  carriage  BUT  is 

    actually  a  1901  Cleveland  Battery - Electric  Buggy  { Quote  --  like 

    their  steam - powered  cousins  they  also  gave  petrol  driven  cars 

    a  run  for  their  money  !! }

     

    Plus  ca  change  ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

    Brian