Which bulb??!!

IanH
IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
1000 Comments
edited December 2016 in General Chat #1

Our Mini has a really useful feature that tells you that a bulb has blown.

Trouble is, it doesn't tell you which one!

So for weeks now, it comes up with a warning every time you start the engine, but try as I might, I cannot find a blown bulb.

Headlights, sidelights, spotlights, front and rear indicators, indicators in the mirrors, rear lights, brake lights, fog lights, high level brake light, number plate light........all checked.

What can it be??!!

Comments

  • Bugs
    Bugs Forum Participant Posts: 480
    100 Comments
    edited December 2016 #2

    Hi Ian

    Sounds like a fault in the system that detects these issues?

    A sender unit maybe or a circuit malfunction?

    Think this will be a garage job so they can hook up a diagnostic system to check it out.

    Bugs

  • peegeenine
    peegeenine Forum Participant Posts: 548
    edited December 2016 #3

    It could be that one of the bulbs has developed a high resistance. If you examine each bulb you may find one that looks black inside and this may be the culprit. Sometimes bulbs need to be changed in pairs as the one on the other side, being older, has a higher resistance than the new bulb. The computer senses the difference in resistance and thinks one bulb has failed.

  • IanH
    IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2016 #4

    Think you are right, Bugs. But it will have to wait for the next service.

    Pee......same answer really. Check every bulb? No, leave it to the experts with the plug in computer, I think.

  • EmilysDad
    EmilysDad Forum Participant Posts: 8,973
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #5

    The bulb check isn't going to monitor every single bulb/lamp on your car. It's likely to check the side lights front & back and headlights if they are normal filament lamps. As suggested above, it could just be a tired bulb or high resistance contact. Another suggestion is, are all the rear bulbs working as they should? eg some cars with CANbus will use an alternative bulb if one has blown, so though you have two/four working tail lights, the car will show up a fault as the incorrect bulbs are on. Not all faults need the relevent 'computer' ... just a little common dog wink

  • Milothedog
    Milothedog Forum Participant Posts: 1,433
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #6

    Just in case it catches you out, be aware that some manufactures fit a single filament bulb to operate as 2 different lights by just changing the light intensity. Vauxhall did this on some models for the Stop & Tail lights. I've know it in the past for people to think the wrong bulb had been fitted.

    Bulbs are cheap (cheaper than a Garage hourly rate) so it's worth taking the advice above and looking at, and changing any that look discoloured or damaged / corroded in any way.  

  • IanH
    IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #7

    But all bulbs are working normally......

  • ABM
    ABM Forum Participant Posts: 14,578
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #8

    HAHA !surprised

    Just  wait  til  you  are  driving  along  in  front  of  young  Constable Keenandclean !  He  will  tell  you  exactly  which  bulbS  are  defective  and  for  only  a  few  quid  each  !!  winklaughing

  • IanH
    IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #9

    It would be a novelty to see Constable Keenandclean out on the street around here, Brian.......

  • Snowy1
    Snowy1 Forum Participant Posts: 263
    edited January 2017 #10

    Fully agree with your above opinions Peegeenine. This can also happen on older vehicles as CAN-bus circuitry on vehicles has now been around since the early 2000's. The CAN-bus circuitry on older vehicles can deteriorate with age and cause changes in circuitry resistance and control signal problems just to mention a few. There are only a few ways of possibly curing said CAN-bus wiring age related problems. Very few dealers are able to find & cure such problems as most staff have no idea where to look as a Plug-in-job does not tell them. In many modern cars; bulb failure systems now detect LED lights as well, in your case, prime suspect to me (if not bulbs) is your highline-stoplight. Why do I say that? I've known on many occasions the high-line stoplight be found to have condensation trapped inside the LED unit. Possible cure! Try drying it out with a hairdryer both inside & out the best you can, then check to see if your bulb failure light goes out.

  • IanH
    IanH Forum Participant Posts: 4,708
    1000 Comments
    edited January 2017 #11

    The car is only 4.5 years old........30k miles......

  • bartdon56
    bartdon56 Forum Participant Posts: 13
    edited January 2017 #12

    i haven't noticed the post for it but seems like the reversing light has blown, similar on my wifes car.

  • Nuggy
    Nuggy Forum Participant Posts: 512
    edited January 2017 #13

    In your list of bulbs you have checked, you didn't mention reversing light / lights, and interior courtesy lights, map reading lights etc etc etc,  are there any in the luggage area?  Recently one of my interior bulbs lead me on a merry dance for ages, tested ok but wouldn't work. The new one does.