Caravans being towed over the speed limit

1456810

Comments

  • brue
    brue Forum Participant Posts: 21,176 ✭✭✭✭✭
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #212

    As someone who has investigated accidents then I have to say speed is often a contributary factor in many accidents. At speed things happen faster and you have less time to react.  The point at which you lose control is easier to reach and in others may
     fail to see you in time. In general driving too fast increases the risk.

    Agreed, plus not leaving enough distance for emergency breaking.

  • SteveL
    SteveL Club Member Posts: 12,311 ✭✭✭
    5,000 Likes 1000 Comments Name Dropper
    edited November 2016 #213

    As I spend 4 months a year on the continent I am surprised I have never seen all those foreign police persecuting British caravanners and they certainly have never targeted me but then I know the limits and try to keep to them. However I did once see the
    French police having a field day with UK registered sports cars on the road to Le Mans when the racing was on. 

    A few years ago a couple of fancy sports cars came past us on the  A26, at a horrendous velocity. We were not towing and had the cruise control set at 130 kph and it was as though we were standing still. The speed was certainly comparible  to when we have
    been passed by the TGV, in areas where motorway and rail run together. At the next peage they were in deep discussion with the police. I assume the booths record the time you pass and if you get to the next one and it flags an average of  260  kph or so, you
    would not have a leg to stand on.

  • Malcolm Mehta
    Malcolm Mehta Forum Participant Posts: 5,660
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #214

    As I spend 4 months a year on the continent I am surprised I have never seen all those foreign police persecuting British caravanners and they certainly have never targeted me but then I know the limits and try to keep to them. However I did once see the French police having a field day with UK registered sports cars on the road to Le Mans when the racing was on. 

    A few years ago a couple of fancy sports cars came past us on the  A26, at a horrendous velocity. We were not towing and had the cruise control set at 130 kph and it was as though we were standing still. The speed was certainly comparible  to when we have been passed by the TGV, in areas where motorway and rail run together. At the next peage they were in deep discussion with the police. I assume the booths record the time you pass and if you get to the next one and it flags an average of  260  kph or so, you would not have a leg to stand on.

    Write your comments here...I'd heard that you can reach the UK national speed limit of 70 mph in second gear with a Porche! I'm not sure how well it would perform as a towcar though!

  • Pippah45
    Pippah45 Forum Participant Posts: 2,452
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #215

    In a former life - my sportscar towed the caravan across Europe brilliantly!  Nothing like a Porche with the engine being 1725 cc (I think) in todays world I am sure it would be illegal to tow what I towed back then! 
    Surprised

  • EmilysDad
    EmilysDad Forum Participant Posts: 8,973
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #216

     ......I'd heard that you can reach the UK national speed limit of 70 mph in second gear with a Porche! I'm not sure how well it would perform as a towcar though!

    My auto Omega would easily do 70 in second too

  • Unknown
    Unknown Forum Participant
    edited November 2016 #217
    The user and all related content has been Deleted User
  • huskydog
    huskydog Club Member Posts: 5,460 ✭✭✭✭✭
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #218

    coming to work this morning on the M20, a 4x4 towing a trailor full of sheep went passed me in the 3rd laneSurprised, when it was safe
    to do so i followed it at a safe distance and the indecated speed on my sat-nav was ......82mphSurprisedYell

    Now ,iv'e heard of fast food ,but............

  • Pippah45
    Pippah45 Forum Participant Posts: 2,452
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #219

    coming to work this morning on the M20, a 4x4 towing a trailor full of sheep went passed me in the 3rd laneSurprised, when it was safe
    to do so i followed it at a safe distance and the indecated speed on my sat-nav was ......82mphSurprisedYell

    Now ,iv'e heard of fast food ,but............

    Write your comments here...Surprised

  • Malcolm Mehta
    Malcolm Mehta Forum Participant Posts: 5,660
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #220

    coming to work this morning on the M20, a 4x4 towing a trailor full of sheep went passed me in the 3rd laneSurprised, when it was safe
    to do so i followed it at a safe distance and the indecated speed on my sat-nav was ......82mphSurprisedYell

    Now ,iv'e heard of fast food ,but............

    Write your comments here...Fast and fresh from what you say! They're livestock. You can't get much fresher than that!

  • Wildwood
    Wildwood Club Member Posts: 3,582
    1000 Comments 250 Likes Photogenic
    edited November 2016 #221

    coming to work this morning on the M20, a 4x4 towing a trailor full of sheep went passed me in the 3rd laneSurprised, when it was safe
    to do so i followed it at a safe distance and the indecated speed on my sat-nav was ......82mphSurprisedYell

    Now ,iv'e heard of fast food ,but............

    Write your comments here... That is just plain stupid, the sheep were probably tightly packed but even so any serious movement at that speed could be a disaster and it certainly shows no respect for the sheep.

  • Pippah45
    Pippah45 Forum Participant Posts: 2,452
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #222

    I witnessed an accident many years ago on the awful road up Loch Lomond to Crianlarich - a sheep transporter had overturned - and all the sheep on the top deck were thrown out - seems it was only licenced to carry the number that were inside the truck! 

    The sheep on the M20 were lucky to survive if they did - and the driver should be taken to the knackers yard - grrrrr. 

  • dave the rave
    dave the rave Forum Participant Posts: 806
    500 Comments
    edited November 2016 #223

    I also use the M20 for my daily commute...it is not unusual to see a vehicle towing a trailer in lane three!!!(only at speed either on a friday morning or after the "rush hour"!!!!!....the offending vehicles are usually ,but not always,foreign registered,unless
    you count irish as english!!!!what is unusual is to see a police motorway traffic car policing!!!!!!

  • Unknown
    Unknown Forum Participant
    edited November 2016 #224
    The user and all related content has been Deleted User
  • Malcolm Mehta
    Malcolm Mehta Forum Participant Posts: 5,660
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #225

    I find it's usually best to add extra time to what the satnav indicates. The satnav doesn't take into account stops or other possible delays.

  • papgeno
    papgeno Forum Participant Posts: 2,158
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #226

    The sat nav in my car adjusts the ETA to allow for stops, slow traffic etc..

  • Unknown
    Unknown Forum Participant
    edited November 2016 #227
    The user and all related content has been Deleted User
  • flatcoat
    flatcoat Forum Participant Posts: 1,571
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #228

    My Co Pilot sat nav enables the user to set required speeds for different road classifications so us have them set at 10Mph below the speed limits upto A Maximum of 50mph. That ensures ETA's are always sufficiently conservative to allow for stops/traffic
    etc. 

  • Malcolm Mehta
    Malcolm Mehta Forum Participant Posts: 5,660
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #229

    My satnav is nine years old and can't even recognise post codes.

  • dmiller555
    dmiller555 Forum Participant Posts: 717
    500 Comments
    edited November 2016 #230

    My satnav is nine years old and can't even recognise post codes.

     

    I'm not suprised, I couldn't either at that age. Winking

     

  • Lutz
    Lutz Forum Participant Posts: 1,564 ✭✭✭✭
    edited November 2016 #231

    A few years ago a couple of fancy sports cars came past us on the  A26, at a horrendous velocity. We were not towing and had the cruise control set at 130 kph and it was as though we were standing still. The speed was certainly comparible  to when we have been passed by the TGV, in areas where motorway and rail run together. At the next peage they were in deep discussion with the police. I assume the booths record the time you pass and if you get to the next one and it flags an average of  260  kph or so, you would not have a leg to stand on.

    I regularly drive at speeds in excess of 200km/h when I visit my daughter because there is usually very little traffic on that stretch of motorway, but that's legal over here in Germany.

  • ocsid
    ocsid Forum Participant Posts: 1,395
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #232

     

    I regularly drive at speeds in excess of 200km/h when I visit my daughter because there is usually very little traffic on that stretch of motorway, but that's legal over here in Germany.

    Now that should give the DPF a decent burn through.

  • RoyandBev
    RoyandBev Forum Participant Posts: 84
    edited November 2016 #233

    on occasions when passing a convoy of trucks I have exceeded the 60mph limit so as not to cause a tailback so presumably I am also tarred by your descriptive name calling

    I have to say, I am guilty of this too, but I don't do it very often!  One problem is that if you 'legally' overtake a truck at the correct speed, it is not always possible to see what is in front.  If there is a line of trucks, one problem is that many
    of these trucks drive so close to the one in front.  To try and 'nose in' can be a little dangerous and not all that desirable! 

    David 

    Good point and I have done same to get past a line (now have motor home but when a van it was well matched to my car at less than 80%) It might be over the legal limit but if you slow down to drop behind the HGVs have to overtake you which is also wrong.

    I also find same on traffic lights changing to red, when approaching I almost always look in mirror and sometimes go over on amber because the car 3 feet of my tail would more than likely not stop even if I can just pull up.

    The letter of the law and spirit of law are separate things and sometimes it can be safer to let the letter drift a bit to avoid a collision, of course there are many drivers reading will have a better solution thinking about it after but in the moment when
    you are overtaking or the lights change or some other event on the road occurs you have a split second to decide on best action.

    That is why in good old days a copper would let you off so long as you were not being an idiot were as today with cameras it is automatic, no room for a warning.

    When I am at 60 on cruse control my sat nav says I am at 55 I am inclined to believe it as HGVs crawl past me and they are restricted so I used to sit at 65 on Speedo and all was well.

    Just my thoughts and I could be wrong

  • Mr H
    Mr H Forum Participant Posts: 356
    100 Comments
    edited November 2016 #234

    Whilst travelling at 60 on the M4 a car passed me, doing at least 75 as he was overtaking cars in the middle lane. He had an old trailer attached with a boat on it. After a further 3 miles or so there he was stopped, with the trailer's axle broken off. Fortunately,
    someone had stopped to assist him as it saved me having to decide to help him as part of me was saying "serves you right" And before I get lambasted, of course I would have helped.

  • JVB66
    JVB66 Forum Participant Posts: 22,892
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #235

    Coming round the M25 near Watford yesterday we were in the middle lane passing an HGV when we were overtaken on the outside lane by a Disco towing an Airstream,we according our sat nav ,were doing 61mph

  • Wildwood
    Wildwood Club Member Posts: 3,582
    1000 Comments 250 Likes Photogenic
    edited November 2016 #236

    on occasions when passing a convoy of trucks I have exceeded the 60mph limit so as not to cause a tailback so presumably I am also tarred by your descriptive name calling

    I have to say, I am guilty of this too, but I don't do it very often!  One problem is that if you 'legally' overtake a truck at the correct speed, it is not always possible to see what is in front.  If there is a line of trucks, one problem is that many
    of these trucks drive so close to the one in front.  To try and 'nose in' can be a little dangerous and not all that desirable! 

    David 

    Good point and I have done same to get past a line (now have motor home but when a van it was well matched to my car at less than 80%) It might be over the legal limit but if you slow down to drop behind the HGVs have to overtake you which is also wrong.

    I also find same on traffic lights changing to red, when approaching I almost always look in mirror and sometimes go over on amber because the car 3 feet of my tail would more than likely not stop even if I can just pull up.

    The letter of the law and spirit of law are separate things and sometimes it can be safer to let the letter drift a bit to avoid a collision, of course there are many drivers reading will have a better solution thinking about it after but in the moment when
    you are overtaking or the lights change or some other event on the road occurs you have a split second to decide on best action.

    That is why in good old days a copper would let you off so long as you were not being an idiot were as today with cameras it is automatic, no room for a warning.

    When I am at 60 on cruse control my sat nav says I am at 55 I am inclined to believe it as HGVs crawl past me and they are restricted so I used to sit at 65 on Speedo and all was well.

    Just my thoughts and I could be 

    on occasions when passing a convoy of trucks I have exceeded the 60mph limit so as not to cause a tailback so presumably I am also tarred by your descriptive name calling

    I have to say, I am guilty of this too, but I don't do it very often!  One problem is that if you 'legally' overtake a truck at the correct speed, it is not always possible to see what is in front.  If there is a line of trucks, one problem is that many
    of these trucks drive so close to the one in front.  To try and 'nose in' can be a little dangerous and not all that desirable! 

    David 

    Good point and I have done same to get past a line (now have motor home but when a van it was well matched to my car at less than 80%) It might be over the legal limit but if you slow down to drop behind the HGVs have to overtake you which is also wrong.

    I also find same on traffic lights changing to red, when approaching I almost always look in mirror and sometimes go over on amber because the car 3 feet of my tail would more than likely not stop even if I can just pull up.

    The letter of the law and spirit of law are separate things and sometimes it can be safer to let the letter drift a bit to avoid a collision, of course there are many drivers reading will have a better solution thinking about it after but in the moment when
    you are overtaking or the lights change or some other event on the road occurs you have a split second to decide on best action.

    That is why in good old days a copper would let you off so long as you were not being an idiot were as today with cameras it is automatic, no room for a warning.

    When I am at 60 on cruse control my sat nav says I am at 55 I am inclined to believe it as HGVs crawl past me and they are restricted so I used to sit at 65 on Speedo and all was well.

    Just my thoughts and I could be wrong

    The maximum speed for trucks is 56 mph. This odd figure is caused by translating the EU regulations in kph into mph. If you are regularly being passed by them at an indicated 60 then your speedo is reading far too high although the odd one might be going
    a bit faster as even things like changing old tyres for new will alter the accuracy.

  • tigerfish
    tigerfish Forum Participant Posts: 1,362
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #237

    But whatever you all say, it is pretty pointless, there is simply no enforcement these days!  You may not have liked the Police traffic patrols, but you were are darned sight safer then!

    TF

  • RoyandBev
    RoyandBev Forum Participant Posts: 84
    edited November 2016 #238

     

    The maximum speed for trucks is 56 mph. This odd figure is caused by translating the EU regulations in kph into mph. If you are regularly being passed by them at an indicated 60 then your speedo is reading far too high although the odd one might be going
    a bit faster as even things like changing old tyres for new will alter the accuracy.

    Tyre size on my Kia Sorento is so critical even tiny differences’ in wear will trick the 4 wheel drive into working, most the owners have like me fitted a mod to switch the automatic 4 wheel drive of completely it is so bad. A variation off 0.5 of a mm on
    the Dia of a tyre makes a lot of difference to the circumference and so the Speedo reading.

    I have found all my cars Speedo reads over compared to sat nav but then again I can’t really check the sat nav so could be anything. My old Galaxy was closest to sat nav at 3mph under at 60 (and I never got passed by HGVs as I remember)

  • Malcolm Mehta
    Malcolm Mehta Forum Participant Posts: 5,660
    1000 Comments
    edited November 2016 #239

    It's 60 mph speed limit for a reason. It's simply not safe to go faster than that. There is a greater risk of snaking or tail wagging the dog as some would say at higher speeds. Below 60 is much safer.

  • Lutz
    Lutz Forum Participant Posts: 1,564 ✭✭✭✭
    edited November 2016 #240

    It's 60 mph speed limit for a reason. It's simply not safe to go faster than that. There is a greater risk of snaking or tail wagging the dog as some would say at higher speeds. Below 60 is much safer.

    Basically you are correct, but 60mph is a generalisation. Some outfits may not recover from an unstable condition without some sort of intervention already at speeds of about 50mph, others may be quite docile at 70mph. Fact is, you can't please all the people all of the time. However, 60mph is a good compromise for an outift that is technically sound and a competent driver.

  • paul56
    paul56 Forum Participant Posts: 937
    500 Comments
    edited November 2016 #241

    Agree Lutz - and for most car/caravan combinations these days it leaves a margin for error ie when a coach/lorry/car transporter blasts past you and the turbulance is manageable rather than catastrophic.